Chocolate Chip Toffee Cookies

Teeny toffee bits take these chocolate chip toffee cookies over the top. Buttery, caramel-y, chocolate-y, chewy cookies with crisp edges (if baked longer). Wickedly good.

Be sure to check out the tweaks you can make to get the kind of cookie you love – cakey, crispy, deeply toffee flavored, even healthier!

These cookies are essentially trumped up chocolate chip cookies with toffee bits and a little bit of healthiness in them. Ok, that might be a bit of an exaggeration, but I figure the oatmeal counts for something.

Needless to say, everyone’s idea of this timeless classic – the perfect chocolate chip cookie – is different.

How do you like your chocolate chip cookies?

The options and promises for the “best” chocolate chip cookie on the internet are endless. Chewy, crispy, cakey, with nuts, with raisins, with oatmeal, with toffee, with brown butter, without butter, without eggs, flat, thick, small batch, you name it. 

The tips are endless too. Use soft butter. Use melted butter. Use unsalted butter. Use salted butter. Chill the dough. Don’t chill it. Mix by hand. Use a mixer. Use dark brown sugar. Use molasses. Use white sugar.  Bake at a low temperature. Bake at a high temperature. Use coconut oil. Use cake flour. 

There are over 1 million google searches per month for chocolate chip cookies and 237,000 search results (mostly recipes) for chocolate chip cookies.

How do you choose? Perhaps this recipe will become your new favorite cookie 🙂 We’ve scoured a ton of popular recipes to help you tweak ours to get to the cookie you will love.

How to get the perfect chocolate chip cookie

Perfect for you, that is.

Our chocolate chip toffee cookies are chewy, buttery and bursting with gooey toffee and chocolate. If you bake them longer, they become darker and crispier.

The recipe below is the way we like them with plenty of raves from others. My son in law says they’re wicked.

Ultimately, it’s best to experiment to achieve your personal preference.

Based on lots of research, here are some tweaks you can try in the recipe as suggested by Food Network, Sally’s Baking Addiction, Pinch of Yum and Joy Food Sunshine.

If you like cakey soft cookies

• Use all brown sugar (not white + brown).
• Add 2 teaspoons of cornstarch. And an extra 1/4 cup/31g flour.
• Don’t over bake.

If you like extra crispy cookies

• Bake at a low temperature (300F/149C) for 24-28 minutes for a flatter, crispier cookie. Food Network suggested this.
• Don’t chill the dough before baking – the cookies will spread out and be thinner. White sugar also helps the cookies spread while baking.
• Or simply bake the cookies as per the recipe for the upper limit of time given.

If you like chewy cookies

• Use our recipe ‘as is’ for a great chewy cookie.
• You can also replace the all purpose flour with cake flour for a chewy, tender cookie with caramelized edges.
• One site suggested using part light brown sugar and part corn syrup (not white sugar)

If you like a deep toffee flavor

• Use dark brown sugar instead of light.
• Add toffee bits (like Skor or Heath bits) as per this recipe.
• Use all brown sugar (instead of a mix of white and brown). The more brown sugar, the darker the cookie and the deeper the toffee flavor.
• Chill the dough for at least an hour or, even better, for 24 hours to deepen the toffee flavors.

If you like healthy-ish cookies

• Swap 1/3 of the all purpose flour with whole wheat flour.
• Add oats (as per our recipe).
• Use less chocolate chips and toffee bits than the recipe calls for.
• Reduce the butter by 2-4 tbsp (in this case, don’t add any additional flour).
• For a vegan, gluten free, health conscious version, check out Oh She Glows cookies.

Tailor To Your Taste

Here are a few further tweaks you can make to adapt the cookies to your preferences.

• Add 1/2 cup chopped nuts, raisins or chopped dried cranberries.
• Sprinkle with sea salt when you take the cookies out of the oven.
• Leave out the skor/heath toffee bits for plain chocolate chip oatmeal cookies.

FAQ

Shortcuts

• Form balls of cookie dough before you refrigerate or freeze them. If you choose to refrigerate the dough before baking (to deepen the flavors and less spread) OR if you are planning to freeze the cookie dough to bake later, form the dough into balls first, place them on a pan, then refrigerate or flash freeze. This will be much easier than working with a block of hard, cold cookie dough.
• Fresh warm cookies in a flash: Once the dough is made, I freeze most of the dough in ball form. Then when I want a dozen or just 2 cookies, I bake them as needed. Like nightly!

Make Ahead, Store and Freeze

• Make cookie dough ahead up to 3-4 days and keep it in the fridge. If you have the room in the fridge, form the balls before putting in the fridge as it’s easier working with softer dough.
• Store baked cookies: Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 3 days. Or freeze them for up to 3 months.
• Freeze unbaked cookies up to 3 months (some say up to a year). Roll small balls from the cookie dough, flash freeze them on a tray in the freezer for 30 minutes, then pile them into a sealed plastic bag or airtight container. When ready to use, bake in a preheated 375F oven for 10-14 minutes. Some say to bring the dough to room temperature first. I don’t bother (I can never wait). You might need an extra minute for the cookies to bake. 

Other chocolate chip cookie recipes to try

• Lazy chocolate chip cookie bars
• Best chew chocolate chip cookies

How to make chocolate chip toffee cookies

This chocolate chip toffee cookies recipe, originally published in 2016, has been updated with new information and pictures. It used to be called Skor Chocolate Chip Cookies.